Notifications
Clear all

Question about my surface grinder attachment

9 Posts
5 Users
1 Reactions
647 Views
Posts: 24
Member
Topic starter
 

Hello. I have recently built myself a surface grinder attachment using the one done by the Red Beard Ops on YouTube as a template.  It works pretty well, however I started noticing that it doesn't leave my surface perfectly flat. What I get is a surface that is wavy, it has a bunch of dips parallel to each other.  What do you think is causing it?   I tried to move the base with the knife at different speeds and it helps sometimes, but I haven't found a reliable way to fix it. Should I perhaps do it for a longer periods of time? I usually do about 10-15 passes on each side.  Or is it something in the construction of my attachment that might be causing it?

Any suggestions would be very welcome.

Thank you!

Luka

 

 
Posted : 06/08/2021 12:33 pm
Ed Caffrey
Posts: 749
Prominent Member Master Bladesmith
 

Taking an educated guess/looking at the pic, what I see is two fold... and possible three fold. Those marks are usually caused by belt joints. The two things that I believe are contributing to your issues are....
1. The build precision of the SG attachment (frankly, I have never see one of the SG attachments that could come even close to a stand alone Surface grinder machine in terms of flatness/precision.)
2. The hardness of the contact wheel you are using. In my experience, what you are seeing/experiencing, is worse with soft contact wheels versus hard ones. (Typical contact wheels that come with most grinders are 70 durometer. Sometimes you can special order a grinder with 90 durometer wheels, but I don't consider even 90 durometer to be hard enough for SG operations. (I personally use urethane on my stand alone surface grinder, with a hardness that is equal to 100 on the durometer scale, which is the highest/hardest the durometer scale goes)

Finally, the type of belt used for SG operations plays greatly into the finish..... I personally use either Norax or Trizact engineered abrasives for my Surface Grinder, and in doing so eliminate those "belt joint bumps".

Ed Caffrey, ABS MS
"The Montana Bladesmith"
www.CaffreyKnives.net

 
Posted : 06/08/2021 3:47 pm
Posts: 24
Member
Topic starter
 

Thank you!  I am indeed using a rubber wheel, so I should probably get something harder. I will start by swapping the belt for a Trizact ones to see how much of a difference it will make.

 
Posted : 06/08/2021 7:52 pm
Joshua C States
Posts: 334
Reputable Member Journeyman Bladesmith (5yr)
 

I sometimes see those marks with my SG attachment (Wuertz machine works) and I have found that moving fast makes them appear, while moving slowly eliminates them. I think Ed is right about it being the belt lap/joint that causes them. Set the motor as fast as it goes, and move the table slowly. See if that helps.

“So I'm lightin' out for the territory, ahead of the scared and the weak and the mean spirited, because Aunt Sally is fixin’ to adopt me and civilize me, and I can't stand it. I've been there before.”

 
Posted : 07/08/2021 9:57 am
Posts: 24
Member
Topic starter
 

Oh, interesting. I was actually trying to do it as quickly as possible based on what the motion looks like in the YouTube videos. But maybe they just speed their videos up to make it look more interesting?  Thank you, I will definitely try that.

 
Posted : 07/08/2021 2:04 pm
Evan Cihak
Posts: 100
Estimable Member Apprentice Bladesmith
 

Ed,

Thanks for the tip about the Trizact belts for surface grinding. Makes sense.

-Evan

Evan L. Cihak

 
Posted : 27/08/2021 9:30 am
James Keeton
Posts: 61
Trusted Member Apprentice Bladesmith (5yr)
 

I second... (or third?) what these gentleman have pointed out on the belts. I found the best SGA performance with a nice new ceramic belt or a trizac. Normal aluminum oxide belts don't fit the bill for these SGAs due to the seam. 

When looking for the best "flatness" on my SGA I will advance the table towards the wheel only ~1-3 thousandths. Then make a very large amount of passes.... in the neighborhood of 20-30

Like mentioned above, these machines really aren't capable of much better than a +/- 3 thousandths variance over about 7'' in my experience. For making full tang knives and flattening Damascus billets, I think they fit the bill. 

I've toyed around with installing a solid metal wheel on mine instead of the contact wheel. This, I think, will make the machine less forgiving and make the surface grinding process more time consuming with smaller advances towards the wheel, however, I think the precision will be higher. 

My SGA:

[img] [/img]

Results with Test Piece and Trizac Belt:

[img] [/img]

J. Keeton
Red Beard Ops

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/RedBeardOps
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/redbeardops/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/RedBeardOps

 
Posted : 04/09/2021 10:16 am
Posts: 24
Member
Topic starter
 

Wow, you just blew my mind. I didn't realize that ceramic belts don't have a seam.  🙂

By the way, thank you for such an excellent video on how to make the attachment. It was a fun build and the resulting tool is extremely useful.

 
Posted : 04/09/2021 11:07 am
James Keeton reacted
James Keeton
Posts: 61
Trusted Member Apprentice Bladesmith (5yr)
 

There are seams, but the "belt bounce" isn't nearly as bad as a J-Flex. Way smoother. I think doing the bulk of the flattening with ceramic, then hitting it with the trizac to dial it in on the SGA is a good order of operations. 

[img] [/img]

Cheers Luka!

J. Keeton
Red Beard Ops

YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/RedBeardOps
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/redbeardops/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/RedBeardOps

 
Posted : 04/09/2021 11:57 am
Share: