You are a funny guy Karl. Nice looking blade there. Can't wait to see the finished product.

If I may make a small suggestion. Hancock taught me that FeCl etches much faster with a bit of agitation. Get yourself a fish tank bubbler and aerate the acid while etching. It really makes the etching process faster and (I think) more uniform.

I keep mine right next to the acid tank. I slotted a scrap of 416 (? maybe nickel/silver) to keep the hose weighted down in the lower part of the tank.

What the agitation is doing is knocking off the steel residue so it doesn't build up and create a barrier on the blade surface.

I'm in no hurry.

But if you had to do a bunch of blades really quickly, that would work well.

I followed-up that video with this quicky:

[media] http://www.youtube.c...s5lli3i1da3o00k [/media]

Thank you for sharing Karl, very helpful indeed.

Super pretty blade there Karl. Was that pressed flat after twisting or beat down with the little Giant? I have a hard time keeping my twists that vertical with my power hammer after drawing down from round.

Again though, turned out great and thanks for the etching tips. I've always thought you had to neutralize with a tsp or whatever between every etch and acetone and dry off and sometimes go into the kitchen and use some dawn just to make sure it's clean again before the next dip. I'm gonna try the old water scrub and dip on the next one I think and see what I see. Thanks again.

|quoted:

Super pretty blade there Karl. Was that pressed flat after twisting or beat down with the little Giant? I have a hard time keeping my twists that vertical with my power hammer after drawing down from round.

Again though, turned out great and thanks for the etching tips. I've always thought you had to neutralize with a tsp or whatever between every etch and acetone and dry off and sometimes go into the kitchen and use some dawn just to make sure it's clean again before the next dip. I'm gonna try the old water scrub and dip on the next one I think and see what I see. Thanks again.

I can think of no logical reason to clean a blade that's already clean, or to neutralize before doing another etching cycle.

That would be a waste of time.

After twisting I mostly forged the blade down with my 50LG. Those twists stayed pretty vertical probably because of the tight twisting.

That came from a twisted bar that looked like this: