Notifications
Clear all

Kerosene Vs Flux ?

83 Posts
27 Users
0 Reactions
73.2 K Views
Mariano Gugliotta
Posts: 19
Member
Topic starter
 

Today I was talking with a colleague who told me that he began to use

kerosene in stead of flux in his damascus welding.

He told me that he stacks the steel and before placing it in the forge

he completely submerge it in kerosene.

Of course today I went and I bought a gallon of kerosene <img src=' http://www.americanbladesmiths.com/ipboard/public/style_emoticons//wink.gi f' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=';)' />

But first thought about asking in the forum, perhaps some one has some

experience in this area.

The question is .... anyone knows about the kerosene method?

Saludos

Mariano

Mariano Gugliotta

 
Posted : 28/05/2010 8:21 pm
BrionTomberlin
Posts: 1675
Member
 

Hello Mariano. I have not used that method, YET, I do plan to try it. At the Spring Hammer In, J.W. Randall gave a lecture and demonstration on advanced damascus. He now uses the kerosene method because of issues with the borax that we are able to get. According to J.W. he very few welding problems with the kerosene. We here is the states have been experiencing more problems getting good welds consistently. Some people, J.W. for one believe it may be due to the borax and the formula being changed. J.w. says that the kerosene of course ignites immediately and deposits a carbon layer which protects the steel so that it is almost a dry weld. I am going to have to try it and see. Let us know your experiences and anybody else that uses it, please pass along your thoughts.

Best regards Mariano.

Brion

Brion Tomberlin

Anvil Top Custom Knives

ABS Mastersmith

 
Posted : 28/05/2010 10:48 pm
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

I was talking with John Perry the other day and he was telling me about J.W.'s talk. I want to try kerosene because borax is nasty and it is eating up my forge. The only problem is that the stuff is not as readily available as it once was. John also told me that he thinks that Chris Marks uses diesel. I hope we can get some good discussion on this topic because i would sure like to find something other than borax. Of course, it goes without saying that you CANNOT reflux with kerosene while forging like you can with borax. <img src=' http://www.americanbladesmiths.com/ipboard/public/style_emoticons//rolleyes.gi f' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':rolleyes:' />

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 12:03 am
Lyman Gerrish
Posts: 15
Member
 

Hey Mariano I think this would be a good subject for your next video.

I am very interested in getting away from borax. I'm thinking that kerosene would work well for cleaning a batch of 1" steel cable I've been sitting on.

Kerosene is a solvent isn't it ?

The last time I used it was in a old hurricane lantern when I was kid.

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 10:04 am
JD Smith
Posts: 51
Member
 

Hmmm...Interesting. I've used kerosene and WD40 in closed dry welds, as in a containment box for mosaic type stuff, but never in an "open" welding situation(a regular billett)I'm having some trouble understanding the chemistry and physics behind the principles that allow a weld with such a procedure. How do the metals in use weld when covered with carbon???

JD Smith

Master Smith

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 10:56 am
Lyman Gerrish
Posts: 15
Member
 

My guess is carbon is allready in the steel part of the chemical make up, thus weldable, the scale from oxidation is a foreign substance maybe not foreign but a by product and is not weldable.

that's just a guess <img src=' http://www.americanbladesmiths.com/ipboard/public/style_emoticons//unsure.gi f' class='bbc_emoticon' alt=':unsure:' />

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 11:17 am
JD Smith
Posts: 51
Member
 

Sure carbon is a part of the steel, but unlike what sits on the surface in the process in question, that carbon is in a solid state solution within the steel itself.

JD Smith

Master Smith

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 1:39 pm
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

Under advice and encouragement from Ron Newton, and after some "white line" problems on final welds with anhydrous borax, I switched to kerosene late last year.

After tacking a stacked billet , and welding on a handle as usual, I stick the billet into a metal bucket of kerosene, entirely submerging the billet. When the billet is placed into the forge( running at 2315 F), the kerosene immediately flames off, leaving an even layer of soot (carbon?) over the entire billet. I do not remove the billet from the forge, or even disturb it, until the forge comes back up to 2300F, whereupon I weld as usual. No splatter, by the way.

I cool the billet, cut, clean, stack, and tack. Then, back into the kerosene, and weld again. So far, I've had only clean, essentially perfect welds in this manner. I believe I can tell that the finished billets are "cleaner" than the" clean" welds I used to get with flux.

I'm sure I can find a way to mess this method up, there always seems to be a new way to make a mistake, but I'm real happy so far....

John White

P.S. I have seen no real theoretical explanation of the kerosene method. It clearly works, and has, for me, some advantages. I plan to discuss this with Kevin Cashen at Blade. I'm sure there are well understood factors at work, here. I just don't know what they are, myself.

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 1:51 pm
Lyman Gerrish
Posts: 15
Member
 

|quoted:

Sure carbon is a part of the steel, but unlike what sits on the surface in the process in question, that carbon is in a solid state solution within the steel itself.

I wonder if the steel incorporates that carbon at the right temp letting it migrate threw out the billet.

If so that could be another small bonus in using kerosene

these are just my thoughts and not based in anything scientific

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 2:16 pm
JD Smith
Posts: 51
Member
 

I'm just trying to think this through. Usually if I don't want metals to stick together I'll lampblack them with an acetylene flame. that's why this sound so strange to me. One can't argue if it's working for other smiths out there, but I'd really like to know the principle behind it. If I know that, I can play with it being better informed about the science behind it.

That white line thing on the last weld,we've all seen those. It's an area of decarb from the forge weld. If the last weld is not done too close to final dimensions(which it shouldn't be)the line will dissapear, as the carbon will have had time to re-migrate into that area.

Anyway, I'm sure we'd all love to eliminate the "self-destucting forge" from using borax. The whole thing sounds like a dry weld. Has anyone tried this using stainless steels yet?

JD Smith

Master Smith

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 5:11 pm
Mariano Gugliotta
Posts: 19
Member
Topic starter
 

Well it seems I'm not the only one trying to get out of flux.

I have long used a mixture of borax and boric acid applying it on the stack with WD40.

I will test the system of kerosene on Monday, I have a W pattern waiting to be welded.

It would be nice to know what chemical effect occurs when using kerosene ...

Saludos and thanks to all

Mariano

Mariano Gugliotta

 
Posted : 29/05/2010 8:46 pm
Posts: 6
Member
 

Really interesting... I'm gonna have to try it too.

 
Posted : 30/05/2010 9:50 am
Rick Baum
Posts: 148
Member
 

Having absolutely no experience with making Damascus, the answer may be totally obvious but... Does anyone know or have any experience with "how Borax vs. kerosene affects performance of a blade"? Is there a difference in edge holding or toughness?

Thanks,

Rick

 
Posted : 30/05/2010 1:14 pm
JD Smith
Posts: 51
Member
 

|quoted:

Having absolutely no experience with making Damascus, the answer may be totally obvious but... Does anyone know or have any experience with "how Borax vs. kerosene affects performance of a blade"? Is there a difference in edge holding or toughness?

Thanks,

Rick

I can't imagine that it would have any effect whatsoever, save the possibility that the additional absorbsion of carbon might affect the steel somewhat and NOT in a good way. I have no idea how much additional carbon gets produced, where it ends up, how much of that is absorbed by migration etc... a lot of questions.

JD Smith

Master Smith

 
Posted : 30/05/2010 4:10 pm
Posts: 0
New Member Guest
 

Spoke with Kevin Cashen re kerosene welding at blade. The visible soot(carbon) which covers the billet right after the kero flames off disappears as the billet heats up. The billet acquires that "translucent" yellow glow as the temp climbs toward 2300 F.

Kevin suggested that at those temperatures that the carbon was certainly not sitting on the surface in a pure state. He assumed that, depending on the atmosphere in the forge, that it was probably present in the form of CO, or CO2, and as such, might be clinging to the surface as an inert atmosphere, protecting the steel from any free oxygen. I did note that I don't disturb the billet til its ready to weld.

This might be a starting place for a hypothesis about kerosene welding, though I don't know of any testing done.

Again, I don't know of any rigorous examination of welding methods. I do know that damascus welds readily and cleanly by this method.

I'd be interested in any scientific info on damascus welding methods.

John

 
Posted : 08/06/2010 7:29 pm
Page 1 / 6
Share: